Sign in

User name:(required)

Password:(required)

Join Us

join us

Your Name:(required)

Your Email:(required)

Your Message :

0/2000

4. Finding, Evaluating and Selecting Suppliers

Author: Jesse

May. 20, 2024

4. Finding, Evaluating and Selecting Suppliers

4

For more information, please visit Arcade Coin Changer Supplier.

Finding, Evaluating and Selecting Suppliers


Note. From geralt, n.d. Licensed for reuse under the Pixabay license.

Learning Objectives

  1. Discuss the various sources of market intelligence.
  2. Recognize the use of market intelligence in identifying potential suppliers.
  3. Understand key supplier evaluation practices.
  4. Explain the need for identifying and evaluating global suppliers.
  5. Understand the key aspects of procurement contract execution.
  6. Implement the various forms of procurement enablers.
  7. Analyze the key forms of documentation used in procurement.
  8. Evaluate key aspects of managing the procurement process and managing the internal processes involved in procuring goods and services.

What do you know about the finding, evaluating, and selecting suppliers?

Flip the cards and match the description to its corresponding image.

Supplier Identification and Evaluation

Supplier identification and evaluation is the process of searching for potential suppliers who will be able to deliver products, materials, or services required by companies. The outcome of this process is to compile a list of potential suppliers. Procurement then takes the lead to evaluate each prospective supplier against specific criteria like cost, quality, consistency, and other performance metrics.

Inclusion and Exclusion for Suppliers

Approved suppliers for a product or service may already exist, which could be the case for repetitive purchases. For items that do not currently have approved suppliers or situations in which organizations want to re-evaluate the existing supply base, evaluations involve identifying possible new suppliers that might be able to satisfy the user requirements.

It is important at this stage to include, where appropriate, possible suppliers that have not previously been used. Identifying possible suppliers, especially in the global business and supply environment, can be a challenge and often requires extensive research.

Importance of the Supplier Identification and Evaluation Process

Among the most important responsibilities of the procurement function are supplier identification, evaluation, and eventual selection. Having fewer suppliers with long-term contracts exposes the form to the risks and costs of making incorrect decisions that can have long-lasting consequences. As suppliers often command a significant proportion of firms’ total spending, the logic behind creating a world-class identification and evaluation process becomes increasingly important. Suppliers also can impact a broad range of end-customer requirements in terms of quality, reliability, and availability of products.

Not all supplier identification and selection decisions warrant the comparable effort. This means the amount of time and effort involved in searching for and evaluating suppliers that provide generic, low-cost items such as motor oil or bandages would be different from the time and effort involved in searching for and evaluating suppliers that provide high-cost, specially engineered items like motor car engines or surgical equipment.

Market Intelligence for Identifying Suppliers

A major request made of supply management tends to be where to find suitable suppliers. The issue of obtaining credible market intelligence confronts supply managers in their efforts to find, qualify, and approve appropriate sources of supply. However, the answer to this seemingly simple request for information (RFI) has many aspects.

The Process of Obtaining Supply Market Intelligence

First, supply departments must identify which potential suppliers exist for a particular commodity and where they are located. Next, they must determine which suppliers are capable of providing the required goods and at what total cost. Organizations must then narrow the supplier pool through a structured evaluation process to arrive at a smaller set of supplier candidates. Lastly, a rigorous evaluation must occur to evaluate suppliers’ past performance and capabilities.

These factors, however, become more challenging when suppliers are located in distant areas. Gathering supply market intelligence (SMI) requires supply managers to obtain and analyze the available intelligence, which is generally more complex and more difficult when suppliers are located in distant areas requiring extensive, and often costly, travel. According to Trent and Roberts (2009), supply market intelligence exists in many forms and places, so no single source of this intelligence is available.

Elements of Supply Market Intelligence

Supply market intelligence is the result of obtaining and analyzing information relevant to companies’ current and potential supply markets with the objective of supporting effective decision-making. According to Dominick (2008), supply market intelligence includes six important elements:

  • Commodity profile information: This information identifies the type and nature of products or services, manufacturing or service delivery processes, and quality requirements or standards.
  • Cost structure: This element consists of the costs associated with capital investment, raw materials, manufacturing, quality, storage, transportation, duties, export control, inventory carrying, taxes, insurance, port of entry, supplier development, energy, overhead, and profit.
  • Supply base information: This portion includes current and potential suppliers, supplier characteristics, and country location.
  • Market information: This information identifies supply and demand price drivers, capacity utilization, and other factors that determine price and availability for the commodities in question, along with the market size and predicted growth rate.
  • Competitive analysis information: This analysis is for buyers’ and suppliers’ relative size and buying power, substitute products and services (i.e., products and services that can be readily substituted for those currently sourced and are comparable at lower prices), other customers using the same sources of supply, and other factors influence buying leverage.
  • Quality: Evaluation of suppliers’ past performance regarding product failure rates and overall quality leading to customer satisfaction. Further evaluation would reveal the extent of quality programs to prevent defects (such as Total Quality Management or lean) and how defects are corrected.

Uses, Categories, and Levels of Market Intelligence

Supply managers obtain and use intelligence to identify suppliers who can provide the necessary products and services that will enable the procuring company to enhance its competitive standing. The intelligence gathered under these categories allows supply managers to make informed decisions about the various supply issues. When collected on a regular basis, this information also allows supply managers to keep abreast of developments, such as shifts and changes in demand and supply markets, the introduction of new products and technologies, the entrance of new competitors, and changes to manufacturing processes. Insights gained from this intelligence help supply departments adjust their sourcing strategies in a timely manner. Market intelligence can be gathered at the following levels:

  • Macro environmental level: Information from this level includes market dynamics, world trade, demographics, political climate, economics, environment, and technology.
  • Country level: This information is often a subset of the macro-environmental level, with additional topics that include cultural issues, levels of crime, logistics infrastructure including the natural geography and size of the country, the safety of intellectual property (IP), political climate and stability, national holidays, working hours, and time zone differences.
  • Industry and commodity level: Industry and commodity market intelligence related to the types, sizes, and relative strengths of industries that exist and the worldwide users and suppliers of commodities.
  • Supplier level: Supplier information comprises the next level of supplier market intelligence and relates to the number of potential suppliers that exist, the products and services they provide, their locations, relative sizes, and capabilities.

Supplier Evaluation

After potential suppliers have been identified, it is necessary to evaluate suppliers. An important step is to pre-screen possible sources of supply to identify the suppliers who meet a minimum set of criteria. Pre-screening reduces the number of potential suppliers to those who can satisfy users’ demands. In some instances, and for some goods or services, pre-screening can be a relatively simple task. In other instances that involve complex items (e.g., jet engines and medical testing equipment), more time and effort are required.

With the potential pool of suppliers reduced to those who can meet users’ requirements, the next step is to determine which suppliers can best meet those requirements. This could be accomplished through competitive bidding if the procurement items are fairly simple or standard (e.g., stationery items, such as pens and paper or consumable maintenance items, such as grease, nuts, and bolts) and if there is a sufficient number of potential vendors. If these conditions do not exist, a more elaborate evaluation, such as engineering tests, may be necessary, and a site visit to the supplier’s facility could be warranted.

Supplier Evaluation Objectives

A key objective in the supplier evaluation process is to identify the suppliers who can become a source of competitive advantage for the procuring company. Another objective should be to reduce risk and maximize value. Risk includes the potential risk of a supplier failure, such as the risk of suppliers not being able to deliver products or services at a consistent level of quality, quantity, and cost over time. With regard to maximizing value, the evaluation process should be able to determine suppliers that are willing to, and capable of, working with the buying company to co-design engineered items, collaborate to reduce total costs, and work together on ongoing quality improvement projects.

The time involved in evaluating suppliers should be related to the importance of items purchased. For example, the effort involved in evaluating suppliers should be different for jet engines than it is for commercial stationery. For the most important goods and services with high engineering complexity or significant cost, organizations should employ cross-functional teams to evaluate suppliers’ financial conditions, capacities, global capabilities, logistical networks, cost structures, supply management practices, process capabilities, technology innovations, quality, and design and engineering capabilities. The time and cost of making supplier visits can be high, but the cost of making a poor selection decision can be devastating.

Supplier Evaluation Criteria

According to Monczka et al. (2005), the following broad criteria are examples of what supply managers should consider during the evaluation process. This list is not exhaustive, but does include some of the more common criteria used in organizations:

  • Location: This criterion lists where suppliers are located in relation to the purchasing firm and the relative advantages and disadvantages of the location, including distance, supply chain infrastructure, and geographic stability.
  • Employee capabilities: This criterion provides a commitment to quality and continuous improvement, the overall skills and abilities of the workforce, turnover, history of strikes and labour disputes, and general morale.
  • Cultural and language differences: This consists of the type of culture in place and any challenges to communicating clearly among parties due to language differences.
  • Cost structure: This includes suppliers’ total costs, including production costs, administrative costs, material costs, supply chain costs, and marketing costs.
  • Infrastructure and assets: This criterion is the age and quality of buildings and equipment and the support infrastructure for maintaining buildings and equipment.
  • Citations and awards: This encompasses reviewing the citations and awards a supplier has received from other customers and local, state, and federal agencies.
  • Working conditions: This is the amount of attention paid to general working conditions, health and safety practices, first aid capabilities, and the use of child labour.
  • Process and technological capability: This includes current and future capabilities in design, methods, equipment, processes, and investments in research and development.
  • Management capability: This broad category includes management qualifications and experience, long-range planning practices, commitment to quality management, customer focus, the history of labour-management relations, investment to sustain growth, employee training and development programs, and strategic sourcing programs.
  • Environmental regulation compliance: This criterion includes demonstrated commitment to the protection of the environment and the level and severity of infractions that have occurred, as well as companies’ capabilities in, and history of, toxic waste management, use of environmentally friendly materials, and use of returnable and recyclable packaging and shipping containers.
  • Financial stability: This entails the financial history of companies, the levels of capital available for investment in companies, credit history, level of debt, and current stability.
  • IT capability: This consists of the types of IT in place, the ability to link and communicate electronically with the technology used at buying organizations or other supply chain partners, and a demonstrated willingness to invest in new technologies.
  • Suppliers’ own supplier network: This includes the nature and extent of the network and the potential risk exposure to target suppliers from their own multilevel supplier networks.
  • Employee turnover: This includes assessing the stability of the workforce by evaluating the tenure of employees and new hires versus terminations and identifying critical skills like welding.
  • Quality capabilities: This consists of the quality assurance systems and procedures in place, workers’ involvement in quality assurance, quality records, and the ability to sustain quality consistency for current demand and anticipated increases in demand.
  • Evaluation of customer base: This entails assessing the degree to which the supplier is dependent on other customers for business; being dependent on only one customer may not enable a supplier to focus on new requirements.

Each of these criteria should also include a set of detailed questions designed to evaluate suppliers’ capabilities with a predetermined scale such as a weighted scorecard shown below,  which is then used to rate suppliers’ capabilities against each of the previously explained criteria. A summary supplier evaluation matrix or scorecard is a weighted scoring framework that may be used to compare the merits of different potential suppliers. Specific criteria are listed and weighted according to their perceived relative merits. Companies are then evaluated on each of the criteria, and weighted scores are tallied across all criteria to determine the best potential supplier.

Current Supplier Evaluation

Sometimes, companies evaluate their current suppliers when they need to source products or services, especially new products or services. These companies will typically identify which of their current suppliers may be capable of providing these products or services and look for other potential suppliers where necessary. Investigating new suppliers can provide a basis of comparison for costs, quality, delivery capabilities, and other supply essentials. Current suppliers’ capabilities will then be evaluated against prospective suppliers’ capabilities to determine how well they fit with particular companies’ needs. For existing suppliers, sourcing professionals have a wealth of information about historical performance that can be used in the evaluation process. This information is helpful, but good performances on contracts in the past do not guarantee good performances on future contracts and different products or services.

Global Supply Management

The search for new sources of competitive advantage is a relentless challenge that organizations face, and it is crucial that supply groups showcase annual progress. Organizations must show constant improvements, particularly cost reductions, which result in a search for low-cost sources of supply that have become a central part of most supply strategies. This has resulted in procurement groups in many companies seeking overseas sources of supply to achieve lower costs.

Sourcing Globally

Most companies are under constant pressure to contain and reduce their costs, which largely explains the motivation behind global sourcing; the primary reason that companies source from around the world is to obtain lower prices. For example, as a cost-cutting measure, Dell moved its European manufacturing plant from Ireland to Poland (Fottrell & Scheck, 2009). This was no small undertaking and affected almost 2,000 employees; however, the move was part of a $3 billion company-wide cost reduction initiative. Other reasons that companies use global suppliers include gaining access to new sources of technology, obtaining a higher quality, or introducing competitive organizations to the domestic supply base.

Global purchasing can result in cost savings, but the global supply process also requires supply managers to address a wider range of issues of cost, time, and complexity. At least a quarter of the unit cost savings from global purchasing disappears, on average, when estimating the total cost of purchase ownership. This is due to hidden costs associated with lengthened supply chains, including increased lead times, increased inventory and increased risks.

Finding Global Suppliers and Supply Classification

Many supply managers use a classification scheme to segment suppliers by their geographic capabilities. This designation helps when searching databases for potential suppliers. In fact, internal supply groups can benefit from this classification in their examination of potential suppliers, whether they are involved with global supply management or not. This approach helps strategy development teams understand the location of suppliers and supplier capabilities more accurately. The classification scheme is as follows:

  • Local supplier: A local supplier serves only a limited number of sites or buying locations (often only one) within a country. The database should include information about the country and the sites within that country that the supplier is capable of serving.
  • Domestic supplier: A domestic supplier can serve any location within a country. The database must note the country or countries that the supplier can competitively serve.
  • Regional supplier: A regional supplier competitively serves many countries within a single region. Examples of regions include North America, Latin America, Asia-Pacific, and Europe. A few suppliers may also serve only a portion of a region.
  • Multi-regional supplier: A multi-regional supplier can competitively serve two or more regions.
  • Global supplier: A global supplier can competitively serve most, if not all, countries around the world.

Purchasing Approval

After suppliers have been selected, evaluated, and approved, procurement departments may choose to utilize those suppliers to provide products and services. This can occur in several ways, depending on the system in place in procurement: awarding a specific purchase order (PO) or a blanket PO, material purchase release, or contract. Developing and awarding POs is an important step because almost all POs include standard legal conditions to which the orders are subject, including the following:

  • PO number
  • Item description
  • Material specifications, including any references to SOWs and engineering drawings
  • Quantity requirements
  • Quality requirements
  • Price
  • Delivery due date and method of shipment
  • Ship-to address
  • Order due date
  • Name and address of purchasing firm
  • Payment terms

Purchasing will typically issue a PO for each required item. Depending on the nature of the item and the relative price of the item, negotiations may or may not be required before awarding the PO.

Weighted Scorecard

A weighted scorecard is a tool often used by procurement to perform an objective evaluation of multiple supplier responses for the same item. It also serves as a permanent record to justify a contractual commitment in the form of a purchase order to the highest scoring supplier. Procurement routinely uses a weighted scorecard process to document key criteria, such as industry experience or financial strength for an item to be purchased and assigns a proportionate value for each criterion.

For example, a company wants to procure an item that will be used in its manufacturing process to assemble an end product. The criteria that are important for this item might be price, delivery, and quality. Percentage values are then assigned for each of the three criteria and several supplier responses are evaluated and compared by populating the weighted scorecard, which defines the comparative value of the criteria.

In developing the weighted scorecard for this example, the criteria (what is important to the company) are defined and listed in the far left column, followed by the weight for each of the criteria. As suppliers’ responses are received, they are scored by entering data into the appropriate columns. These scores are then mathematically calculated into points for each supplier; the points are totaled to determine the award.  Supplier B scored the higher value compared to supplier A. The purchase order would be awarded to supplier B. 

Figure 3.1

Weighted Scorecard Comparing Supplier A vs B

 

Note. From Snage. [Image Description]

Blanket Purchase Orders (BPOs)

Blanket purchase orders (BPOs) are typically used when the same materials or services are ordered on a regular basis, whether on a consistent, periodic schedule like cleaning services or on an as-needed basis when quantities fall below desired levels, such as when materials for a manufacturing process run low. When using this type of purchasing arrangement, buyers and suppliers work together to evaluate the anticipated demand for specific items required for a defined period of time and agree on the terms of the agreement. Buyers also reserve the right to cancel BPOs in the case of poor supplier performance or changes in demand.

The BPO is established as a master agreement; buyers subsequently use material release documents at periodic intervals, as necessary and based on usage, to order items covered by the BPO. This material release typically specifies the required part number, quantity required, unit and quantity price, required receipt date, ship-to address, and method of shipment.

Award Purchase Orders

In this step, POs are awarded and released to the supplier, and deliveries are subsequently received by the ordering organization. Many organizations transmit orders electronically through electronic data interchange (EDI); orders can also be transmitted over the Internet. After the award, procurement is also responsible for monitoring the status of open POs, expediting orders, and providing ongoing administration for other tasks.

Goods Receipt

The goods receiving process involves several processes and documents, including a material packing slip, bill of lading, and discrepancy report, each of which is explained further below.

  • Material Packing Slip: This includes weights, dimensions and the quantity of units used in the transportation. The goods receiving process involves several processes and documents, including a material packing slip, bill of lading, and discrepancy report, each of which is explained further.
  • Bill of Lading: Transportation carriers issue a bill of lading, which records the number of goods delivered to a location on a specific date. The bill of lading details the number of boxes or containers delivered; other details about the shipment appear on packing slips and are the suppliers’ responsibility for recording on this slip. The bill of lading also ensures that carriers are protected against wrongful allegations that they have damaged, lost, or otherwise tampered with the goods they have delivered.
  • Discrepancy Report: Receiving discrepancy reports are used to record any differences between goods received and goods ordered; discrepancies are recorded by the receiving clerk during the receiving process. Procurement groups use the discrepancy report to follow up and resolve any issues with suppliers.

Evaluate Supplier Post-Purchase Performance

When products and services have been delivered, supplier performance must be evaluated to determine if they have actually met the requirements of the procuring organization. Firms should determine whether suppliers have performed according to requirements by using a system for measuring performance. When supplier performance does not satisfy the requirements of the procuring organization, the discrepancies must be identified and recorded, and corrective actions must be undertaken by working with the supplier. The precise nature of feedback to suppliers varies among companies, but feedback must occur at a prescribed frequency. This enables procuring organizations to work with suppliers to identify defect trends, implement corrective actions to fix those defects and take preventive actions to eliminate recurrences. Some examples of feedback are:

  • Weekly performance metric reports
  • Quarterly, mid-level review meetings for supply chain managers between buyers and suppliers
  • Annual, executive-level meetings about SCM between buyers and suppliers

Procurement Enablers

A variety of tools and techniques are available to procurement professionals; they can be used to enable and support the sourcing process. This section outlines these tools and techniques, and provides examples of best practices, including the following:

  • E-procurement and electronic purchasing
  • Procurement cards
  • Long-term purchasing agreements
  • EDI
  • Electronic catalogues

E-Procurement and Electronic Purchasing

E-procurement is an Internet process used to make the procurement of goods and services easier, faster, and less expensive for businesses. The overall goal is to streamline the purchasing process so that businesses can focus more management time on earning revenue and serving customers. According to EPIQ (2014), e-procurement does not work for all items purchased by firms. For instance, items of strategic importance to firms, such as custom-designed engines for a package transportation vehicle, are typically not purchased using e-procurement. However, many noncritical items like stationery are well-suited to be purchased using these types of systems.

Procurement Cards

Procurement cards are essentially credit cards provided for internal users to purchase low-cost items without having to go through procurement’s administrative process. Procurement cards work well for low-cost items that are required on an as-needed basis; they are especially helpful when approved suppliers for low-cost items do not exist and where suppliers are not approved by other purchasing systems.

Authorized procurement cardholders make the buying decisions, up to the value allowed on the procurement card and within the prescribed budget of the department that is making the purchase. The monetary value of items purchased and covered by procurement cards is typically low and might consist of brochures for a trade show or conference. In these cases, the cost of involving procurement groups in a supplier search, evaluation, and approval process would typically outweigh the cost of items purchased (Monczka et al., 2005).

Long-Term Purchasing Agreements

Firms enter into long-term agreements with suppliers they plan to work with over an extended period of time. Long-term agreements involve base contracts that are generally in place for a year or more. These types of agreements are similar to a BPO process but are established to cover the purchase of higher-value items over a long period of time, such as special packaging supplies, machine maintenance parts, and high-value raw materials. Long-term purchase agreements can reduce transaction costs by eliminating the need for time-consuming renewals of purchases.

In addition, when buyers and suppliers agree on contract terms, material-releasing responsibility can shift to users in many cases. This means that end-users arrange directly with suppliers for products required to be delivered without involving procurement at all. Ideally, material releasing is accomplished electronically instead of manually, which saves time and money (Monczka et al., 2005).

Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

EDI involves a computer-to-computer exchange of information. It can be used to support transactions between buyers and sellers, allowing for greater efficiencies and streamlined communication. This, in turn, can lead to less time and money dedicated to the procurement process.

Electronic Catalogs

Electronic catalogues provide a user-friendly way of accessing information about a supplier’s products and services. The chief benefit of using electronic catalogues is their low-cost search capability; if users order directly from these catalogues, cycle times and ordering costs can also be reduced. Pricing is often included as part of the catalogue and is referred to as a published price list. Procuring organizations with higher buying volumes may be offered a percentage discount on the rates from the published price list.

Automation of Bidding

At many firms, entire bid processes have been automated. Bid packages and specifications are made available online from which bidders submit their bids and proposals, and the bid openings and awards are communicated electronically. Cycle-time reductions and other cost savings can be significant if the automated process is efficient.

In online auction situations, potential sources are also prequalified and invited to take part in the online bidding. The auction, or event, is set for a specific date and time period, much like the deadline and bid opening deadlines of offline processes. An auction’s success depends, in large part, on the quality of bid specifications and the ability of procurement professionals and processes to prequalify suppliers. In an online environment, bidders can see the actual bid amounts but not who is involved in the bidding.

Procurement Documents

Procurement departments utilize and maintain certain documents for purchases. The types of documentation kept will depend on the organizational requirements and will differ for each organization. A number of procurement documents are used to obtain information and proposals from prospective suppliers. These include the following:

  • Request for Information (RFI): An RFI is a document that companies send to potential suppliers requesting key information, including products or services provided, length of time in business, and markets served.
  • Request for Proposal (RFP): A request for Proposal (RFP) is a document that companies send to approved suppliers requesting them to submit a proposal that outlines how they would complete the scope of work along with pricing, quality, and delivery data.
  • Request for Quote (RFQ): An RFQ is a document that companies send to approved suppliers requesting price quotations for products or services.

The terminology may vary among industries, and in some organizations, the preparation and use of the previously mentioned documents is a specialized field assigned to certain individuals. Procurement groups typically use standard documents to obtain the necessary information from prospective suppliers.

Commonly Used Procurement Documents

According to Muckstadt, Murray, Rappold, and Collins (2003), a number of documents are commonly used in procurement. These include the following:

  • Requisition: A requisition is a request outlining requirements for products or services that normally takes the form of a hard-copy or electronic document created by the demand planning organization; after approval, it is forwarded to the specific procurement organization.
  • Sourcing information/justification: These are documents that are used to record the reasons for the procurement method and the types of suppliers used; for example, if the purchase is made from a sole-source supplier, the document explains why no other sources are available.
  • Statement of Work (SOW): An SOW is a formal document that details the work activities and tasks suppliers must carry out, the products or services to be delivered, and a planned timeline for completion. The SOW normally includes highly detailed requirements, prices, terms, and conditions.
  • Contract: An agreement between two or more parties with the terms and conditions of the work to be carried out, the products or services to be provided, timing, fees, and deliverables. Contracts can be verbal or written but are usually written documents that involve an offer and the acceptance of an offer.
  • Requirement definitions: Requirement definitions are formal, clear definitions of the products or services required and include product specifications, performance requirements, quality specifications, and SOWs.
  • Bill of materials (BOM): A BOM is a document that accompanies engineering drawings, in which parts, materials, labour, etc., are listed. A BOM itemizes what is required to manufacture an item; it enables suppliers to price accurately the work on which they are bidding.
  • Shortlist: A shortlist is a list of candidates, normally potential suppliers, who have been selected for further review or for final consideration before actually approving a supplier and awarding a contract.
  • Progress reports: These are accounts of the advances made in fulfilling the contract or proofs of delivery of goods and services at required times, in required quantities, and at acceptable levels of quality.
  • Correspondence with a contractor: This comprises all interactions about the work to be carried out or the work being carried out along with the products and services being provided.
  • Proof of payment: The proof of payment indicates that payments have been made to suppliers by buyers’ accounts payable departments.
  • Offers received (technical and financial): The offers received (technical and financial) document comprise the various offers received from potential suppliers to a request for tender—a formal, structured invitation to suppliers to bid on supplying products or services—and contain the necessary information about suppliers’ technical and financial capabilities and other strengths relevant to the work required by buyers.
  • Evaluation report: The evaluation report is developed based on a review of the information provided by suppliers in response to RFIs, RFQs, or RFPs; it comprises an assessment of potential suppliers’ capabilities about the work required or products and services to be provided. This report is also referred to as a weighted scorecard.
  • Proof of receipt of goods: The proof of receipt of goods document is signed by buyers to indicate that they have received the required goods. One copy of this document is normally kept by buyers, while another copy is returned to suppliers.
  • Receipt and inspection reports: The receipt and inspection reports are about inspections carried out on goods delivered to buyers and about the quality of the goods received; they detail any issues about quality, quantity, and inconsistency.
  • Supplier evaluation reports: These reports are normally developed on a scheduled basis; they indicate how well suppliers are performing in their contractual, and other, obligations.
  • Amendments to solicitation documents: Amendments to solicitation documents list any changes, deletions, or additions to the RFI, RFQ, or RFP, and any other clarifications and correspondence with suppliers.
  • Amendments to contracts: The amendments to the contracts document includes any agreed modification to contracts.

Key Takeaways

Discovering potential suppliers is the process of searching for suppliers who will be able to deliver the products, materials, or services required by a company. The outcome of this process is the list of potential suppliers, after which procurement evaluates each prospective supplier against specific criteria like cost, quality, consistency, and other performance metrics. Obtaining suitable market intelligence is an issue that confronts procurement managers daily in their efforts to find, qualify, and use appropriate sources of supply. Additionally, supply departments must identify which potential suppliers exist for a particular commodity and where they are located.

Supply market intelligence is the outcome of the process of obtaining and analyzing information relevant to a company’s current and potential supply markets with the objective of supporting effective decision-making. Supply market intelligence includes five elements: commodity profile information, cost structure, supply base information, market information, and competitive analysis. Supply market intelligence also has varied uses. Supply managers obtain and use intelligence to identify suppliers that can provide the necessary products and services at consistent levels of cost, quality, and quantity. The evaluation of potential suppliers attempts to answer two main questions: Is this supplier capable of supplying the purchaser’s requirements satisfactorily over both the short and long terms? Is this supplier motivated to supply these requirements in the way that the purchaser expects over the short and long terms?

The main objective of the evaluation process is to reduce purchase risk and maximize overall value, and the time that goes into evaluating suppliers should be a function of the importance of items purchased. Suppliers are generally rated across multiple categories using weighting evaluation criteria, according to the relative importance of each criterion. Most firms engage in global sourcing at some level, and the primary reason to source on a worldwide basis is to obtain lower prices. Many firms source globally and have realized savings as a result. Supply managers from leading companies have developed a classification scheme to segment suppliers by their geographic capabilities.

Tactical aspects of the procurement process to enable the placement and approval of POs with suppliers, the information needed for a comprehensive purchase requirement, the necessary forms and documents, and the necessary elements in the post-award process that must be managed. Additionally, alternate forms of procurement were reviewed, including procurement cards for non-procurement personnel, electronic catalogues for requisitions, and EDI and bidding automation, both of which used to streamline procurement processes.

Review Questions

References

Dominick, C. (2008). Buyers ask: What is market intelligence? Next Level Purchasing Association. http://www.nextlevelpurchasing.com/articles/what-is-marketintelligence.html

EPIQ. (2014). Electronic procurement. https://www.epiqtech.com/E-Procurement-Systems.htm  

Fottrell, Q., & Scheck, J. (2009, January 8). Dell moving Irish operations to Poland. The Wall Street Journal.
http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB123141025524864021

geralt. (n.d.). Business establishing a business [Computer graphic]. Pixabay. https://pixabay.com/illustrations/business-establishing-a-business-3639463/

Monczka, D., Trent, R., & Handfield, R. (2005). Purchasing and supply chain management (3rd ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

Muckstadt, J. A., Murray, D. H., Rappold, J. A., & Collins, D. E. (2003). The five principles of supply chain management: An innovative approach to managing uncertainty. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/The-Five-Principles-of-Supply-Chain-Management-An-Muckstadt-Murray/c407061b21531ff22515a14cd52b65e232b3b33b.  

Trent, R. J., & Roberts, L. R. (2009). Managing global supply and risk: Best practices, concepts, and strategies. Plantation, FL: J. Ross.

Creative Commons Attribution

This chapter contains material adapted from Supply Management and Procurement Certification Track. LINCS in Supply Chain Management Consortium. March 2017. Version: v2.26. www.LINCSeducation.org.

Image Descriptions:

Figure 3.1: This figure is a weighted scorecard, and it is a tool often used by procurement to perform an objective evaluation of multiple supplier responses for the same item. It also serves as a permanent record to justify a contractual commitment in the form of a purchase order to the highest scoring supplier. On the right side of this figure, there are four criteria that each supplier gets weighted for integrity, industry expertise, experience and qualification and financial and managerial strength. Supplier A scored a total of 1.90 and Supplier B scored a total of 2.75. Supplier A scored a higher weight than Supplier B in financial and managerial strength whereas Supplier B scored a higher weight than Supplier A in both industry expertise and experience and qualification leading Supplier B to be chosen. [Back to Image]

28 Questions to Ask on a Discovery Call During the Sales ...

Sexy as closing calls may be, they don't happen without solid discovery calls laying the groundwork. The smoothness of your sales process, the quality of your sales conversations, and ultimately, the difference between a closed-won deal and one that hits a wall can all rest on the success of your discovery.

Not all prospects are created equal — so no matter how sound your offering might be, there‘s no universal guarantee that everyone you talk to is a perfect fit. A well-structured, thoughtful discovery call gives you a sense of the size and viability of a deal — cueing you into whether the 10 to 20 hours you’re going to spend with a prospect will be worth the effort and resources.

Now, you might be thinking, “These discovery calls sure do sound important — but where on Earth can I go to learn more about them?” Lucky for you, you‘re in the right place. Here, I’ll offer more context about what discovery calls are, the best questions to ask whether your prospect is a good fit, and some handy discovery call scripts. So what are we waiting for? Let's dive in!

Table of Contents

What is a discovery call?

A discovery call is the first conversation a seller makes to a prospect after they show interest in that seller's offering. The purpose of a discovery call is to tease out a prospect's pain points, discuss goals, build rapport, and ultimately determine whether they're a good enough fit to continue moving through your sales process.

The discovery call is your tone-setter, and I mean that in a few ways. For one, it's the first opportunity you have to talk to your prospect at length — making it crucial in establishing sound rapport.

It also gives you valuable context about your prospect‘s goals, needs, interests, and pain points — giving you a roadmap for how to most effectively structure your sales efforts around your prospect’s specific circumstances.

In short, it can be the difference between establishing an authoritative relationship or spending your whole sales process playing catch up.

Admittedly, I‘ve made my fair share of shoddy, shallow discovery calls at points in my career. The result? I’ve had an equally fair share of unduly complex deals that I thought would be straightforward.

Why are discovery calls important?

Discovery calls are central to understanding any prospect‘s situation. And that makes sense — you can’t understand the nuances of what a potential buyer is dealing with if you don‘t ask them about, well … what they’re dealing with.

Luckily, in my experience, prospects are generally okay with participating in a discovery call — so long as it's not an interrogation.

Discovery calls pose some key benefits, including:

  • Helping your prospect understand your business and product. These days, buyers are as empowered and well-informed as they‘ve ever been. Still, I’ve found that there‘s almost always room for them to learn more in discovery. A discovery call provides a forum for you to answer your prospect’s specific questions about your product and, in turn, gauge and capture their interest.
  • Showing you’re invested in your prospect’s success. A thoughtful, well-executed discovery call shows your prospect that you understand their problems and will make a concerted, professional assessment to see if you can help them — demonstrating that you care about their success, not just their money.
  • Giving you a sense of whether you can actually win their business. I've had my share of ultimately doomed deals that I wasted a lot of time and effort on — and in some cases, that stemmed from undercooked, poorly executed discovery. These kinds of calls give you an opportunity to qualify your prospect, providing the space to learn their pain points and degree of organizational influence. Discovery calls help you get a sense of whether they have a bonafide need for your offering and whether your contact will advocate for you. Incorporating a sound qualification framework like BANT (or an alternative) helps you get this done.

As you can probably tell at this point, I‘m a big discovery call guy. I sincerely believe that delivering on yours is critical to a successful sales process — so at this point, you’re probably thinking, “Oh baby, Dan! I‘m sold on this whole ’discovery call' thing! But where do I go from here? How in the gosh darn heck do I handle these calls?”

To that, I say, “Good question, reader!” Here's the answer — asking the right questions. Let's take a look at some of the questions I often incorporate into my discovery calls.

We're committed to your privacy. HubSpot uses the information you provide to us to contact you about our relevant content, products, and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more information, check out our Privacy Policy

Free Guide: 101 Sales Qualification Questions

101 Questions to Ask Contacts When Qualifying, Closing, Negotiating, and Upselling.

  • Budget Questions
  • Business Impact Questions
  • Competitor Questions
  • And More!

Loading your download form

You're all set!

Click this link to access this resource at any time.

Download Now

Discovery Questions

Discovery questions are questions you ask a prospect to gauge whether or not they are a good fit for your product or service. These questions should be open-ended and focus on the prospect’s obstacles, processes, and goals as they relate to the product or service you are offering.

For context, sales discovery generally involves four parts: setting the stage, qualifying the prospect, disqualifying the prospect, and establishing next steps. You won’t be able to cover every question listed here on every call — and it might not make sense to — but I find as you go along, you should get a sense of the right questions to ask.

You‘ll notice that all of the questions I’ve listed are open-ended — that's because you want to get your prospect talking on a discovery call. If you limit a prospect to “yes” or “no” answers, you limit your ability to get as robust a picture as possible of their circumstances.

Let’s take a closer look.

Questions That Set the Stage

This is where you validate your research and learn about the customer’s situation. This gives you the proper insight you need to move forward.

1. Tell me about your company.

This seemingly simple question begins with an easy topic: The prospect’s own company. This gives them a chance to introduce themselves on their own terms, but be careful — if you ask this question too early, it might seem like you didn’t do any research at all. I generally begin by stating what I already know, then I ask this question, so they can build upon my description of their business.

2. Tell me about your role. What do you do day-to-day?

With this question, you can begin to find out more about the employee (not the business) in a more casual, low-pressure way. I don't dive too deep into the details when I ask this question. Keep things lower stakes here — and in my experience, prospects are usually excited to share.

3. What metrics are you responsible for?

Here’s where the pressure begins to mount. I find that prospects don‘t always touch on what they’re responsible for when asked the previous question. You need to ask this to uncover that information. The language here is also very important — I always use the word “metric.” You need to ask about a quantifiable measure of success. That will allow you to concretely quantify how your offering can improve that metric.

Questions That Qualify

After you’ve learned about your prospect, it’s time to identify their goals and clarify their pain points. You can use the Budget, Authority, Need, and Timeline (BANT) framework to help formulate the questions you'll be asking during your discovery call.

Learn about their problems so you can solve for the customer.

4. Tell me about your goals (financial, customer-related, operational).

In many cases, I append a timeline to this question: "Tell me about your goals for the next month/quarter/year" — adding that kind of specificity tends to produce more pointed, valuable insight. I usually choose a timeline depending on the implementation process of my product. For instance, if I was selling an enterprise-level tool that takes six months to set up, I might ask about yearly goals instead of monthly goals.

5. When do you need to achieve these goals?

While the prior question might hint at a timeline, this question explicitly asks when your prospect must achieve the goal. A yearly goal might be "To increase revenue by 5% year-over-year,“ but the cut-off date for that is in three months, just in time for the New Year. ”Yearly“ does not mean ”next year." It could be as soon as this quarter.

Additional reading:
Apatosaurus Pictures & Facts

The company is the world’s best Claw Machine Custom supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.

6. What problem are you trying to solve?

Does this question seem vague to you? That's because it is, and I have a good reason for that — that vagueness prevents you from pigeonholing a prospect into giving you a certain answer. I always want to give them a chance to bring up any problem they're facing. That way, I can get a better sense of their business challenges at a more overarching level.

7. Are you having problems in [area as it relates to the product]?

This question lets you lock in on the nuances of your prospect's pain points after the one above. I still keep things open-ended with this one, but now, I drive them toward a specific area of their business. I know this is technically a “yes or no” question — but it still prompts a prospect to think more deeply about their challenges.

8. What’s the source of that problem?

I always ask this question right after the previous one — that sequence lets me uncover key pain points or areas of friction. My prospect might not know what their problem is, but if I don‘t understand why they’re having the problem, I can't hone in on the source as something I can eliminate. Knowing the source of the problem is key to creating an irresistible sales pitch.

9. Why is it a priority today?

I‘ll occasionally skip over this question — but only if my prospect naturally reveals why their problem is a priority in the previous answer. That said, if I think asking this will give me a better sense of exactly why the problem they mention is a priority, I’ll go ahead and do it. It can provide valuable context around how urgent this problem is for your prospect.

10. Why hasn’t it been addressed before?

I find that knowing the roadblocks a prospect has faced in solving their problems can hint at their current roadblocks (or the ones they might face down the line). For instance, when a prospect cites budget as an issue with me, I know to focus on that as a qualifying factor.

11. What do you think could be a potential solution? Why?

I ask this question to find out how a prospect envisions resolving their problem — even if the answer might not include my solution. Asking this gives you a sense of where their strategic vision and priorities lie. It offers a valuable look at how they problem-solve, giving you some perspective on how to tailor your value proposition to suit how they think.

12. What would a successful outcome look like?

I ask this to get a sense of what their image of success looks like, and it's not always realistic — but it generally gives me a picture of whether my solution legitimately suits their ideal outcome. Listen without judgment here, but be sure to take note of their expectations to confirm whether you can actually help.

13. If you didn’t choose a product, do you have a plan in place to address this problem?

This question always gives me a sense of how urgently they need a solution for their challenges. If they say they don‘t have a plan in place or can’t envision solving the problem another way, then I know they're not a good-fit prospect.

Questions That Disqualify

Next, ask questions that might disqualify the prospect. Find out what you can about the decision process, from budget to scheduling.

14. What are your primary roadblocks to implementing this plan?

Even if I have an idea of the roadblocks a prospect will face, I still ask this question to get a straight answer from them. Sometimes, you need to put a prospect on the spot a bit — a frank question like this can get you some hard context on what they're facing.

15. What’s your timeline for implementation?

This question is one of the more important ones I‘ve listed here. If their timeline and my timeline aren’t compatible, I can more or less automatically disqualify them. The “T” in BANT is there for a reason — asking this question is the easiest way to reveal that context.

16. What’s the approximate budget for solving this problem?

Here‘s another frank, necessary question. You always need to know if there’s enough money for them to invest in a new product or project if you‘re going to allocate the time and resources for a sales engagement. I find that when it comes to sales, it’s never too early to talk about budget.

17. Whose budget does the funding come from?

Measure up the tone of the conversation before asking this question. It might be too probing for a prospect who’s not well acquainted with you yet. If you and the prospect are on comfortable terms, find out where exactly the money will be coming from.

18. Is the budget owner an “executive sponsor”?

An executive sponsor is a senior-level employee who’s directly involved in a project and is committed to its success. Whether that’s your prospect’s direct manager or a C-suite executive, it’s important to know whether the owner of the budget is a single person or the entire department.

Questions that Establish Next Steps

Lastly, ask questions that move the prospect along the pipeline. Provide a solution and offer next steps.

19. Who else will be involved in choosing a vendor?

This is a critical question for understanding whether your prospect is a gatekeeper, influencer, or decision-maker. Indirectly, you’ll also find out just how involved the decision-making process is.

20. Do you have written decision criteria for choosing a vendor? Who compiled these criteria?

If you’re speaking with a smaller firm, then the answer will most likely be no. But this question is important if you’re working with enterprise businesses. Try to get access to the decision criteria if possible.

21. Have you purchased a similar product before?

Knowing what your prospect has tried before will be instrumental in establishing a competitive advantage. You should be prepared to uphold your product above the competition’s even if the prospect doesn’t mention them by name.

22. Is this a competitive situation?

Who else is your prospect considering purchasing from? This question will uncover that without sounding whiny or defensive.

23. What’s the process for actually purchasing the product once you decide on it? Are there legal or procurement reviews?

If you’ve gotten to this point, you’ve probably built a high level of trust with your prospect. So you can ask right out about the purchase process without pushing them away.

24. What are potential curveballs?

While question #14 alluded to roadblocks, this question will reveal if there will be any unexpected changes that might bring the deal to a halt. Plus, if the prospect didn’t share too much when you asked about roadblocks, this question could do a better job of uncovering them.

25. How can I help make this easy?

The prospect might not have anything for you, or they might ask for additional resources and documentation. Either way, you want to give them a chance to articulate ways you can make the process easier.

26. How will this solution make your life better?

You can instill relief in your prospect by helping them envision how their work life will improve after they purchase your product. This will do a lot of work when it’s time for your prospect to present your solution to stakeholders.

27. If you implement this solution, how do you hope things will be different in one year?

Will they have more customers? Or will they have wasted less time doing menial tasks? Again, nudge them to envision how things will be better with your product on hand.

28. Can I follow up with you on mm/dd?

Close the call strongly by suggesting a date to follow up.

You’ll know that you’ve run a good discovery call if you and your prospect are able to create a written sales plan and delineate the next steps. If there’s still uncertainty when you hang up the phone, schedule another call to iron out remaining details.

Next, I'll review the sales discovery process, talk about how to run a discovery call and share a full discovery call template that you should follow for a greater chance of success.

Sales Discovery Process

In the sales discovery process, you will research your prospect, connect by phone, ask them key qualifying questions, answer any questions they have, solve their challenges, and hopefully move them along the sales pipeline.

This process is the first step in the connect phase of the sales process — and while it might revolve around teasing pressing and relevant insight out of your prospect, you can't go into it knowing absolutely nothing.

A discovery call calls for some prep work. If you approach your prospect without any context, you can‘t ask the kind of questions that will reveal the kind of information you need to thoughtfully consider whether they’re worth your time. You‘ll also run the risk of undermining your credibility with a prospect by coming off as disorganized — or you might lead them to believe that they’re just another name on a list for you.

Research the prospect and their company.

Spend as much time as you can researching and understanding your prospect’s business. Know their vertical, their challenges, and their goals. Take a look at their engagement history with your company — how did they demonstrate interest in you?

For instance, if they downloaded a guide on your website about SEO best practices, you can deduce that they might be struggling with their existing organic search demand generation infrastructure.

Having that kind of insight cues you into their goals and needs — and leveraging that perspective can inform much more thoughtfully tailored, effective discovery questions.

This sales meeting playbook can help you target your research efforts.

Gather what you’re looking for in a customer.

A discovery call‘s value goes both ways. You’re not just looking to impress a prospect — you're trying to determine whether a sales engagement with them is worth your time and effort.

That's why thoroughly understanding what you're looking for is just as important as understanding what they're looking for. Have a comprehensive understanding of your ideal customer profile and buyer personas.

Know who buys from you — along with what your solution can and can‘t offer them, their ideal price points, their buying habits, their typical pain points, and any other information that helps you understand the rationale behind your solution’s typical purchase.

All of this will help you structure the kinds of discovery questions that will reveal whether the prospect has needs and interests that align with your most productive customers.

Separate your questions into 4 segments: Staging, Qualifying, Disqualifying, and Next Steps.

An effective discovery call isn't haphazardly strewn together. It needs to have some degree of structure — arranging the call with this progression is one of the more straightforward, productive ways to get there.

Share relevant insights.

Social proof and hard data are two of the most valuable resources you can leverage during discovery. People trust industry peers and numbers more than they do a random salesperson on the other side of a call.

Having content like relevant case studies or recent research on hand to help give context and reassurance to prospects can go a long way on a discovery call. Reassurance and urgency are two of the most important elements for supporting virtually every aspect of the sales process — and discovery calls are no exception.

Showing that your offering has helped similar businesses or pointing to broader industry trends that your solution suits particularly well can help reveal business needs or pain points they might not have considered and establish that your offering can accommodate them.

Be ready to connect your solution to the prospect’s goals.

Discovery calls are primarily related to qualification, but that‘s not where their utility ends — they also provide an excellent forum for hard selling your solution. They allow you to introduce the ways your solution can suit your prospect’s needs and interests.

That‘s why you need to have a sense of a prospect’s goals — and that generally comes from conducting thorough research ahead of the call and practicing active listening throughout it.

If you conduct your call right, your prospect may very well mention their goals and pain points explicitly — but they'll also allude to more “under the surface” ones they might not have considered.

Regardless of what the insight you get out of them might be, find a way to align your solution with it. Connect what you do with what they need — briefly speak to the benefits they can expect to see.

Be careful though, you‘re not closing on this call, so don’t get too caught up — that can read as overbearing or aggressive. Check out these sales pitch examples if you’re looking for inspiration.

How to Run a Discovery Call

1. Research your prospect’s business ahead of time.

I mentioned it earlier, but I'll say it again — spend as much time as you can researching and understanding your prospect’s business. In my experience, under-preparing for a discovery call is the easiest way to simultaneously undermine your ability to ultimately appeal to a prospect and wind up wasting your time on a deal that goes nowhere.

A discovery call is an invaluable opportunity — you get the chance to convey value towards the beginning of the sales process and gauge the viability of a potential sales engagement before you invest extensive time and resources in it.

If you don‘t do your research, you’re selling yourself extremely short.

2. Create an agenda and send it to your prospect.

Every sales meeting needs structure, direction, and clarity — and discovery calls are no exception. They may seem lower-stakes because they occur towards the start of the sales process, but in my experience, that's the worst possible mindset to approach them with.

I‘d go so far as to say that discovery calls have some of the highest stakes of any sales conversation because they decide where the deal will go. So you need to establish a clear picture of what’s going to happen on the call.

Doing so will help bolster your authority, let prospects know that you value their time, and if things don't pan out, give you a clearer frame of reference for where you have room for improvement.

Send your agenda to your prospect ahead of time, and give them the flexibility to add any more items they see necessary — that will ensure you're covering everything they want to talk about.

3. Set a time and date that works for both of you.

When you send the agenda, set a time and date that works for both parties. Ask your prospect how much time they’ll have. If they’d prefer to meet for 30 minutes instead of an hour, take that into account.

Depending on their flexibility, you might even be able to do a product demo during the discovery call. Be careful with this approach: If you demo the product too early, you might forget to focus on the prospects’ needs and challenges.

4. Open the call conversationally.

I find that discovery calls can be a little awkward for salespeople and prospects, alike — so always keep things light and approachable at the start. Open it up with some easy conversation.

Ask how their day or week has been, or what they did over the holidays, and as you go into the following steps, be sure to keep the tone conversational. This isn’t an interview — it’s a way to get to know each other better.

5. Set the stage.

It’s time to use the discovery questions above. These questions are a great place to start:

  • Tell me about your company.
  • Tell me about your role. What do you do day-to-day?
  • What metrics are you responsible for?

You can skip the last question if they share their metrics of success when they describe their day-to-day work.

6. Qualify the prospect.

Just by the previous questions alone, you’ve probably gotten a good idea of whether your product can help. Further qualify the prospect by asking at least three of the following questions:

  • Tell me about your goals (financial, customer-related, operational).
  • When do you need to achieve these goals?
  • What problem are you trying to solve?
  • Are you having problems in [area as relates to the product]?
  • What’s the source of that problem?
  • Why is it a priority today?
  • Why hasn’t it been addressed before?
  • What do you think could be a potential solution? Why?
  • What would a successful outcome look like?
  • If you didn’t choose a product, do you have a plan in place to address this problem?

Remember to keep the tone conversational. These questions should flow naturally.

7. Ask disqualifying questions.

It’s just as important to disqualify the prospect as it is to qualify them. That way, you don’t waste your time. Ask the following questions:

  • What are your primary roadblocks to implementing this plan?
  • What’s your timeline for implementation?
  • What’s the approximate budget for solving this problem?
  • Whose budget does the funding come from?
  • Is the budget owner an “executive sponsor”?

Feel free to make the tone less conversational here and get a little more firm. You want the prospect to think carefully through their answers and not just throw out the first thing that comes to mind.

8. Establish next steps.

Last, set up next steps. There should be no question about what the prospect (or you) should do to move the deal forward. Be sure to ask:

  • Who else will be involved in choosing a vendor?
  • Do you have written decision criteria for choosing a vendor? Who compiled these criteria?
  • Have you purchased a similar product before?
  • Is this a competitive situation?
  • What’s the process for actually purchasing the product once you decide on it? Are there legal or procurement reviews?
  • What are potential curveballs?
  • How can I help make this easy?
  • How will this solution make your life better?
  • If you implement this solution, how do you hope things are different in one year?
  • Can I follow up with you on mm/dd?

Discovery Call Template

You‘ve done your research, have your questions ready, and are set to begin your first discovery call. But if you’re new to sales or are trying to meet aggressive goals, it can be tough to keep conversations casual.

If you need some inspiration to keep the conversation flowing, it can help to have a discovery call template with some quick discovery call scripts, like the ones below.

These suggestions are organized in chronological order, so you can create a custom template from the choices in each section, or pick and choose from the sections that are most useful for you. Doing so can help you structure a thoughtfully constructed discovery call script to reference when making your calls.

Introduce yourself.

  • “Hi there, [prospect’s name], it’s [name] with [company name]. It’s a pleasure to speak with you today. I’m hoping to learn more about your business and how we might be able to help.”
  • “Hello [prospect’s name], I‘m [name] with [company name]. I’ve been doing some research on [your company] and I’m impressed with what I’ve seen so far. I’d like to learn more about [name a specific goal, challenge, or opportunity] to see if there is a way we can work together.”
  • “Good [morning/afternoon] [prospect’s name], it’s [name] with [company name]. I was initially referred to you by [referral name]. They mentioned you're looking to [insert potential pain point]. I’d love to learn more about your situation and see if we can help.”
  • “Hey [prospect’s name], it's [name] from [company name]. I recently noticed [something positive about the company/compliment]. I wanted to connect with you to see if there might be a way we could work together.”

Create a connection.

  • “Just so I can make sure I understand your needs, could you tell me a little about what your company has been focusing on lately?”
  • “What challenges are you currently facing with [related pain point]?”
  • “I noticed your background in [related industry or experience]. I've actually worked with a few companies in your industry before. Can you tell me more about your current situation?”

If these starters feel too fast or formal for your prospect, check out this list of conversation starters.

Set expectations.

  • “Just a heads-up, our call shouldn‘t take more than [specific time you have in mind]. I’m hoping to get a better understanding of your business and the challenges you're facing. Does that sound good to you?”
  • “I'm looking forward to our call today. My goal is to get a better understanding of your current situation so that I can see how we may be able to help. How does this fit with your objectives for the call?”
  • “To make the most of our time, I‘ve prepared an agenda with a few items I’d like to discuss. We'll start with [first item] and move on to [subsequent items]. Do you have any questions before we get started?”
  • “By the end of our call today, I hope to have a clear understanding of your business and goals and share how we could help. Then the next step would be for us to schedule another call to dive deeper. Does that sound like a good plan?”

Find top pain points.

  • “I have a few questions I‘d like to ask to get a sense of your organization and the challenges you’re dealing with.”
  • “I saw on your website that you recently posted a [blog/article] about [topic related to pain point]. Can you tell me more about the situation that led you to publish that post?”
  • “I've been talking with other companies in your industry and it seems like [pain point] is a common challenge. Is this something your team is experiencing too?”
  • “I know it's been a tough time for businesses in your industry. What challenges have [your organization] faced over the past few months?”

In addition to the qualifying questions above, creative open-ended questions are a great way to surface pain points.

Figure out how pain points impact your contact.

  • “Thank you for telling me about what your organization is dealing with right now. How do you think these challenges are impacting your role?”
  • “I'd like to get a better understanding of [pain point] you mentioned. How does [pain point] impact your business and goals?”
  • “Just curious, what happens if [pain point] isn't addressed? What are the potential consequences?”
  • “How do those challenges impact other departments or stakeholders? Would it make sense to collaborate to solve [pain point]?”

Find and explain your best solution.

  • “Based on what we've discussed, it sounds like [product/service] might be a good fit for your organization. Can I give you a quick overview?”
  • “I've been thinking about how we might be able to help solve {pain point]. Our [product/service] is designed to [brief value proposition]. Would you like to hear more about it?”
  • “I've been through similar challenges with other clients in the past. We were able to help them by [brief case study or testimonial]. Does this sound like it would work for you?”
  • “It seems we both feel [related topic] is important, and our conclusions on [pain point] align with that. Do you think [product/service] could improve your situation?”
  • “Can you walk me through the specific needs of [project], so I can share how we can customize [product/service] to meet those needs?”

Anticipate and handle objections.

  • “It sounds like you may not be ready to put this solution in place. Let's address any concerns so we can find a way to work together.”
  • “I've found that some clients are hesitant to move forward because of [related objection]. Do you want to share your thoughts on this?”
  • “It‘s not unusual to have concerns about trying something new. I’m here to listen to any objections you may have so we can fully address them.”
  • “Some people may not be ready to use a new resource because of [related objection]. We‘ve gotten results for other clients with similar challenges. I’m here to work with you to develop a solution that meets your specific needs.”

This guide to objection handling is essential if objections are a deciding factor in the outcomes of your discovery calls.

Summarize your conversation.

  • “Thank you for taking the time to speak with me today. Based on our conversation, it seems like your top priorities are [insert priorities]. You're looking for a product that can help you [goals for solution or product]. Is that right?”
  • “To summarize, it sounds like you're facing [insert challenges] and you want a solution that can help you [insert priorities]. Does that sound right to you?”
  • “To recap, you're looking for a tool that can help you with [insert priorities]. And the features that are most important are [insert features]. Is that a good summary?”

It's also a good idea to take notes on your summary so that you can include specific details in your follow-up email.

Confirm the next steps.

  • “To pin down the next steps, I‘d like to learn more about [questions you didn’t get to ask during the conversation].” After this intro, follow up with Qualifying Questions, Disqualifying Questions, or Questions that Establish Next Steps.
  • “Thanks again for your time today. Based on what you've shared, it seems like the best next step is for me to send over some more information about [specific product or features]. Does that sound right to you?”
  • “To get started, we‘ll need to complete some specific steps. First, I’ll [specific action, like send you a proposal], and then we can schedule a call to review it. How does that sound to you?”
  • “It sounds like we agree that [product] can help solve [pain point]. What would be your ideal next steps to move forward?”

Discovery Call Tips

1. Prioritize qualification over process-based questions.

Focus on whether the prospect is ready for your product before figuring out how to implement it. For example, a legal or procurement process isn’t a roadblock to a sale, but a lack of a business plan is.

Get the big-ticket items out of the way first. For example, establishing a pain point or goal and talking through potential choices. Then you can move on to the details of the deal.

2. Confirm understanding before moving to the next question.

Clear communication will make the difference in whether you close a sale. It can be tempting to jump to the questions that will bring you closer to close, but that could lead to missed opportunities.

Let your prospect share any insights that could give you context for their business needs and goals. “Why” questions can help you uncover the root of a prospect's challenges. They can also help you understand what has motivated them to find a solution and how urgent the problem is.

3. Keep asking questions until you fully understand your prospect.

Ideally, a discovery call will either clearly surface a sales opportunity or definitively disqualify a prospect. You should come out of your calls with an understanding of your prospect’s needs and how you can help solve them.

4. Utilize active listening and open-ended questions.

Shane McEvoy, Founder of Flycast Media, says, "Over the years, I‘ve honed a couple of secret moves for discovery calls that really pack a punch. First off, active listening isn’t just a buzzword in my playbook — it‘s the golden key. Locking into every word a prospect says lets me dive into understanding the exact pain points they’re wrestling with. It helps me gather the intel needed to tailor a pitch-perfect solution that resonates on a personal level.

"It‘s how I turn lukewarm leads into raving, loyal clients. Then, there’s the art of the open-ended question — my go-to tool for getting prospects to spill the beans. These are the kinds that invite a story, drawing out the juicy details you can‘t get with a simple yes or no. It’s like opening a door and inviting them to walk me through into their world, revealing the hidden gems of what they really need.

“This approach, done right, can skyrocket conversion rates and increase client satisfaction tremendously. It proves that a dash of curiosity and a genuine desire to connect can transform a run-of-the-mill call into a game-changing conversation.”

5. Add value in small and subtle ways.

Always add value to each discovery call. This may mean offering recommendations or simple ways to help. And be sure to personalize so your value-add doesn't seem self-serving.

If you leave the prospect with a positive impression, they are more likely to reach out when they become sales-ready (if they aren’t currently).

6. Set a positive tone with transparency.

According to Lilia Tovbin, Founder and CEO of BigMailer.io, transparency is central to productive discovery calls. According to her, you need to "[be] upfront about your intentions and the purpose behind the discovery call.

"From our experience, being transparent right from the start sets a positive tone and promotes trust with the prospect. This helps align our expectations and ensures that both parties are on the same page, which is crucial for a fruitful discussion.

“I recall a recent discovery call with an e-commerce client. Right from the outset, we transparently mentioned that we wanted to explore how our platform could provide solutions that fit their needs. This immediately created a favorable ambiance for the conversation, as the client appreciated our honesty. It also encouraged them to openly share their challenges and eventually allowed us to be part of achieving their goals.”

7. Personalize your strategy with empathy and research.

Aseem Jha, Founder and Head of Customer Delivery at Legal Consulting Pro, says, "Imagine stepping into a discovery call armed not just with a pitch, but with a personalized strategy that resonates deeply with your prospect. As a seasoned sales leader, I‘ve learned that the secret lies in meticulous preparation coupled with genuine empathy. Before the call, delve into your prospect’s world — understand their industry, challenges, and aspirations.

"During the conversation, prioritize building a rapport that goes beyond the transactional. Share insights gleaned from your research, but more importantly, listen intently to their story. It's in these moments of active listening that you uncover the nuggets of information that can transform the trajectory of your sales pitch.

“I‘ve found that by focusing on understanding rather than simply selling, I’ve not only closed deals but forged lasting partnerships. This approach isn‘t just a strategy; it’s a mindset shift that has consistently delivered results in my sales journey.”

8. Highlight consequences to create urgency.

Lev Tretyakov, CEO and Sales Director of Fortador, "I explain what would happen if they do not solve the problem. We often focus on discussing what would happen if they solve the problem and forget to address what would happen if they don't, which is the key to creating urgency. Ask second and third-layer questions like, ‘How will this impact your business’s revenue, cost, and risk?' This week, I was talking with a potential client who was concerned about the efficiency of their cleaning solutions.

"He felt their cleaning was not up to par. Moving beyond the immediate benefits of our steam cleaners, I steered the conversation to discuss what would happen if they did not upgrade. They would incur more maintenance costs, lower customer satisfaction, and risk of shutdown due to noncompliance with health regulations.

“This highlighted the benefits of our products but created a sense of urgency and necessity. People appreciate it more when you come off as a consultant. So, make a real human conversation beyond checking off a list of questions.”

9. Align value with your client's goals.

Kristy Galea, Director Of Sales at Cadence SEO, says, “When conducting discovery calls, I begin the conversation around the client's goals and build the call around how value can be attributed to those goals and benchmarks — overall, discussing value and educating the client on how they can solve the issues promptly. Their needs are the most important at all times.”

10. Approach calls with a learning mindset.

Chris Riley, Founder of Cuppa AI, says, "My top tip for conducting effective discovery calls is to go in with a learning mindset, not a selling one. Ask open-ended questions to deeply understand your prospect‘s key challenges and priorities. Listen for what’s not being said, read between the lines, and probe further.

“Too often, reps go into calls with a rigid agenda, talking over the prospect. An effective discovery call should be a conversation, not a pitch. Let the prospect‘s challenges and needs guide the discussion. The more you listen, the more they’ll open up. And the more they open up, the better equipped you'll be to provide real value. An insightful discovery call builds trust and sets the foundation for a long, successful partnership.”

11. Follow up promptly and thoroughly

Samantha Odo, Real Estate Sales Representative and Montreal Division Manager at Precondo, says, "It‘s crucial to establish a clear agenda for the call. Let the client know what topics you’ll be covering and what they can expect from the conversation. This helps set expectations and keeps the call on track.

"Always follow up on any action items or next steps discussed during the call. Whether it‘s sending additional information, scheduling a follow-up meeting, or providing answers to specific questions, make sure you’re proactive in moving the conversation forward.

“These strategies have been instrumental in my success as a real estate sales representative. By setting clear agendas, asking open-ended questions, actively listening, and following up diligently, I‘ve been able to build strong relationships with clients and ultimately close more deals. Give them a try, and I’m confident you'll see positive results too.”

Great Discovery Calls Will Help You Close More Deals

Investing time and energy in creating a great discovery call will let you know for sure whether a prospect is a good or poor fit for the product. This will help you focus your time on the prospects who are more likely to close. This can help you exceed quota and become a standout performer in your team.

Editor's note: This post was originally published in October 2015 and has been updated for comprehensiveness.

 

Are you interested in learning more about White Claw Claw Machine For Sale? Contact us today to secure an expert consultation!

54

0

Comments

0/2000

All Comments (0)

Guest Posts

If you are interested in sending in a Guest Blogger Submission,welcome to write for us!

Your Name:(required)

Your Email:(required)

Subject:

Your Message:(required)

0/2000